Building Critical Readers Teaching Students to Evaluate Text

Teach Students to Think Critically About What They Read!

Do your students take everything at face value, or do they question, analyze, and form their own opinions? 

Teaching students to evaluate texts strengthens comprehension and builds critical thinking skills.

Why Teach Text Evaluation?

✔️ Encourages deeper thinking beyond just “liking” a book
✔️ Strengthens comprehension by analyzing key story elements
✔️ Helps students recognize bias, perspective, and author’s purpose
✔️ Prepares students to make independent, informed judgments

Easy Ways to Teach Evaluation in Your Classroom

📖 Model with Read-Alouds verbalizing your thoughts – Pause and ask: Why did the author make this choice? Do I agree? How does this compare to another book?

             📌 Try this: Read a picture book or article aloud and have students use evaluation stems (e.g., I agree/disagree with the author because… or This text is effective because…).

📝 Use Graphic Organizers:  paper and digital

Guide students in analyzing plot, characters, and writing style.

Give students a framework for evaluating texts through graphic organizers, checklists, and response sheets.

          📌 Try this: Provide students with an Evaluation Checklist to assess a book’s plot, characters, setting, and writing style.

💬 Book Clubs & Small Groups – Encourage discussion, debates, and text comparisons. 

                      📌 Try this: Have students rate a book’s effectiveness in conveying its theme or debate whether a character’s choices were realistic.

📌 Ready to get your students thinking deeper?  

 Start today📥 Grab this Evaluation Toolkit and start transforming your readers today It's one of my popular resoruces.

Looking for more insight, ideas, tips for the reading classroom.  Hit the follow button

#ReadingComprehension #CriticalThinking #TeachingReading #DeepThinking